In the world of personal finance, being able to max out both a company 401k and a Roth IRA is the holy grail for diligent savers. It's a huge commitment to long-term financial independence and taking advantage of those super-powerful tax-advantaged accounts. But the burning question for a lot of Americans isn't so much whether it's a good idea – it's whether this kind of aggressive saving is actually normal for most people in the current economic climate.
Let's be straight up: consistently putting the max allowable amount into both your 401k and a Roth IRA is a seriously impressive feat. For 2026, that means you can contribute up to $24,500 to a 401k (or $32,500 if you're 50 or older) and another $7,500 to a Roth IRA (or $8,500 if 50 or older). That's a combined annual savings of $32,000 for those under 50, just from these two vehicles, without even counting any employer 401k match, or other investment accounts – that's a lot of cash set aside for retirement! This level of dedication to retirement planning is certainly a very commendable financial goal, but the reality is that it's far from the norm for the majority of the working population.
The Reality of Retirement Savings in America
While maximising these powerful investment strategies is the ideal scenario, the truth for many households is a juggling act of competing financial priorities - a messy web of have and have nots. High inflation, rising interest rates, student loan debt, houses that just keep getting more expensive, and childcare costs just drain your disposable income. For a big chunk of the population, just scraping by and meeting your monthly bills, leaves little room for aggressive savings, let alone hitting the max contribution limits for multiple retirement accounts.
Have a look at the average American's financial situation. A lot of folks are still dealing with credit card debt, building up their emergency fund or saving for a down payment on a house. These are all super important financial goals that often take centre stage or run alongside retirement savings, making it tough to find tens of thousands of dollars a year to put into tax-advantaged accounts. The data from various financial institutions and government bodies says that while a lot of people are participating in 401k plans, the average contribution rate often falls short of the max, even when an employer match is on the table. For example, a recent Fidelity analysis found that the average 401(k) contribution rate (employee plus employer) was 14.2% in 2025, a level that still falls short of the max cash limit for many income levels.
Getting Over The Roth IRA Hump
The Roth IRA – a fantastic wealth-building tool with tax-free withdrawals in retirement – is a real all-rounder for those wanting to build a nest egg. But it comes with its own set of hurdles beyond just finding the spare cash. For instance, putting direct contributions into a Roth IRA is subject to those pesky Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) limits. In 2026, the IRS has not yet released official MAGI thresholds, but historically they rise slightly each year. That means many higher-income folk – those who might otherwise be able to max out their contributions – actually need to go the “backdoor Roth IRA” route. Doing this adds yet another layer of complexity to their investment plans.
Even for those below the income limits, coming up with an extra $7,500 a year (or more) after having potentially splurged on a 401k contribution of $24,500 is no mean feat. And that's on top of needing to set aside an annual savings target of $32,000 – a pretty sizeable chunk of income for anyone earning under six figures, even if they are earning a decent wage. In reality, it demands a lot of careful financial planning and being really disciplined with your budget.
Who Typically Maxes Out Both?
Generally, folks who consistently max out both their 401k and Roth IRA tend to have a thing in common:
- Higher Earners: It's no surprise that those with a higher income have more flexibility to allocate a decent amount of cash to long-term savings.
- Budgeting Pros: These individuals tend to be super careful with their money - they have tight budgets, prioritise saving over spending on want rather than need, and keep debt (when they have it) to a minimum.
- Early Birds: Loads of people who save aggressively started doing so early in their careers, which means their savings get to compound over time and makes keeping up the good work easier.
- Employer Matching: Grabbing a generous employer match on a 401k is just common sense for those wanting to make the most of their retirement savings.
- Debt-Free: Those without any crippling debt - student loans, credit cards etc - have a lot more cash to put towards their savings.
While its not the norm, as in it's not what the average person does, it is something a lot of people aim for & can reasonably achieve. The path to financial security & retirement planning is a very personal one. For some folks, maxing out both accounts is a realistic target, but for others, just contributing what they can, consistently, is the way to go - and that's equally valid. The key is to understand how these tax-advantaged accounts can really benefit you & to put as much as you can into them, while always trying to increase your savings rate over time. And if you want more details on IRA contribution limits, you can always have a look at official sources like the IRS website. What others are saving can also give you a bit more context to work with - you can find that in reports from big financial institutions such as Fidelity's Retirement Analysis.
Post a Comment